Fogarty's Facebook




Taste of Key West – 11.95

Assortment of Fish Bites, Conch Fritters, & Fried Shrimp


Fish Bites – 7.95

Select Fresh Fish fried golden brown, served with Tartar sauce


Conch Fritters - 6.95

Key West Classic with Bahamian Conch & Island Spices


Key West Crab Cakes - 10.95

Lump Blue Crab Cakes fried golden brown and

served with our special Remoulade Sauce


Tex-Mex Rolls  - 8.95

Chili Dusted Grilled Chicken, Roasted Corn, Black Beans, Cilantro, Peppers, Onions, Jalapenos, and Cheddar & Jack Cheeses in a Golden Brown Egg Roll


Bruschetta - 7.95

Grilled Baguette topped with chopped Roma Tomatoes, Garlic, Basil, Olive Oil, Fresh Mozzarella, & a Balsamic Vinegar Glaze


Quesadilla -6.95

 Grilled Flour Tortillas with Melted Cheese, Grilled Onions, Green Peppers, & Jalapenos.  Served with Salsa & Sour Cream

Add Shrimp or Chicken  2.95


Lettuce Wraps - 9.95

Grilled Satay Chicken, Carrots, Cucumber salad,

Coconut Curry Noodles, & Thai dipping sauces.

Roll it up in crisp, fresh Boston Lettuce leaves & enjoy.


Sliders – 8.95

3 mini burgers with Grilled Onions & Pickles


Peppered Ahi Tuna – 9.95

Rare Ahi Tuna rolled in Fresh Cracked Black Peppercorns.  Served with Spicy Red Chili Soy & Wasabi


Buffalo Chicken Tenders - 8.95

Boneless Chicken Strips, dipped in Hot Cayenne Pepper Sauce served with Celery & Bleu Cheese. (Very Spicy)


Peel & Eat Shrimp –  ¼ Pound  6.95           ½ Pound 11.95

Steamed Shrimp, chilled & served with our  Tangy Cocktail Sauce & Lemon.





Pecan Encrusted Mahi-Mahi – 19.95

Fresh Filet of Mahi-Mahi, brushed with honey, crusted with Pecans, deglazed with Chardonnay,  Key West Sunset Sauce, Rice, & Vegetable Garnish


Mixed Grill – 17.95

Sautéed Scallops and Shrimp topped with a Lime Cilantro Sauce, served with Rice & Vegetable Garnish


Baha Fish Tacos - 17.95

Floured and Lightly Seasoned Fried Select Fish served in a warm Flour Tortilla with Chili Cream, Mixed Cheese, Bahamian Coleslaw, Mandarin Oranges and topped with Crispy Corn Strips, Cilantro and served with Rice & Beans & Salsa


Crusted Chicken Romano – 15.95

Parmesan and Romano Crusted Chicken Breast with Minced Garlic , and a Creamy Marinara over Penne


Lime Cilantro Chicken - 17.95
10oz Marinated Airline Chicken Breast in our own Lime Cilantro Dressing, served with Rice, Black Beans, Corn Chips, and Salsa


Broccolini – 15.95

Grilled Chicken Breast, Penne Pasta, & Fresh Broccoli

in a creamy Parmesan Sauce


Three Cheese Pasta – 14.95

Penne Pasta with Marinara Sauce, Parmesan, Mozzarella & Ricotta Cheeses, & Garlic with fresh Basil


Blackened Rib Eye – 20.95

14 oz. Hand Trimmed Rib Eye Crusted with Cajun spices served with Mashed Potatoes, Vegetable Garnish, & Fried Onions


Filet Mignon – 22.95

9 oz. Beef Tenderloin cooked to perfection, served with

Mashed Potatoes & Vegetable Garnish


Smokey Joe’s Ribs – Full Rack - 24.95     Half Rack – 18.95

Slow roasted Baby Back Pork Ribs with sweet and smoky

BBQ Sauce, Mashed Potatoes, Onion Strings & Cole Slaw.



Mashed Potatoes - 2.95                                            Cole Slaw - 2.95
Dinner Salad - 3.95                                                                   Rice - 2.95
Broccoli - 3.95                                                          French Fries - 2.95




Soup of the Day– 4.50

Ask your server for today’s selection


Bahamian Conch & Clam Chowder – 4.95

Tomatoes, Potatoes, Carrots, Celery, Island Spices, & lots of Conch & Clams





Grilled Tenderloin Tip Salad – 10.95

Marinated Grilled Tenderloins served over Romaine Lettuce with Candied Pecans, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Cucumber, and Tomatoes, served with an Asian Dressing


Chinese Chicken Salad – 10.95

Crispy Chicken with Sesame Sauce, Wontons, Rice Sticks, Almonds, Green Onions, Mandarin Oranges, & a blend of Lettuces, tossed in Caroline’s Asian Vinaigrette


Fogarty’s Chopped Salad – 13.95

Grilled Mahi-Mahi and Shrimp with Romaine Hearts, Mango’s, Cucumber, Tomato, Almonds, & Hearts of Palm, Tossed with Balsamic Vinaigrette


Caesar Salad – 7.95

Romaine Hearts, Parmesan, Croutons, & Romano cheese

Add Blackened Mahi-Mahi Filet or Gulf Shrimp  4.00

Add Grilled Chicken Breast  3.00


Ahi Salad – 12.95

Sesame Crusted Yellowfin Tuna cooked rare with diced

Tomatoes, Cucumbers & rice sticks, served over a bed of Mixed Organic Greens & our own Balsamic Vinaigrette


Santa Fe Chicken Salad – 10.95

Diced Chicken Breast, Roasted Corn, Black Beans, Tomatoes, Cheddar & Jack Cheeses with Tortilla Strips, & our own Lime Cilantro Dressing


Cobb Salad – 10.95

Romaine Hearts, Crispy Bacon Crumbles, Hard Cooked Eggs, Diced Tomatoes, Grilled Chicken Breast, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, & House made Balsamic Vinaigrette


House Salad – 5.95

Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Carrots & Croutons, atop a mix of Fresh Lettuces




All sandwiches are served with French Fries.


Dolphin Sandwich – 10.95

Char-grilled, seasoned with Lemon and Herbs, Grilled Onions, Lettuce, & Tomato


Fogarty’s Fish Sandwich – 9.95

Fried Golden Brown Filet, served with Lettuce, Tomato, & Tartar Sauce


Blackened Shrimp Wrap – 9.95

Spicy Shrimp, Crumbled Bacon, Romaine Lettuce, Diced Tomatoes, Parmesan Cheese, & Tangy Caesar Dressing


Shrimp Po Boy – 9.95

A bunch of fried Key West Shrimp with Lettuce, Tomato,

& Caper Remoulade


Shrimp & Bacon Club – 9.95

Grilled Gulf Shrimp, Smoked Bacon, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, & Tomato Basil Dressing


Duval Club – 9.95

Smoked Turkey, Ham, Swiss Cheese, Crisp Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, & Mayonnaise on Toasted Whole Wheat


Ragin’ Cajun Chicken – 7.95

Blackened Chicken Breast smothered with Grilled Onions, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, & our Special Cajun Sauce


Cheesesteak – 9.95

Fresh Shaved Rib Eye topped with Smoked Provolone, Mushrooms, Onions & Peppers


Fogarty’s Burger – 9.95

Thick Chopped Sirloin, grilled to perfection,

served with Lettuce, Tomato, & Grilled Onions


BBQ Bacon Burger – 11.95

12 oz. Burger topped with BBQ Sauce, BBQ Ranch, Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, & Fried Onion









Classic Key Lime Pie    3.95

Big Fat Chocolate Cake     5.95

New York Cheesecake     5.95


Souvenir Cups ::: $7.00

Squeeze Bottles ::: $10.00 {Refills ::: $7.00}

Jumbos ::: $16.00 {Refills ::: $12.00}



Grain Train

Mix of 3 Grain Alcohol Flavors:

Grainorade, Mojo, & Howler


Rum Runner

151 Rum, Dark Rum & Fruit Juices


Pina Colada

Creamy Coconut, Pineapples & Rum


Strawberry Daiquiri

Fresh Strawberries & Rum


Third Degree Burn

151 Rum, Bourbon & Fresh Fruit Juices


White Russian

Vodka, Coffee Liquor &

Vanilla Ice Cream



Grain Alcohol, Vodka & Orange


Ruby Roo

Fresh Raspberries 151 Rum & Bourbon



Grain Alcohol, Vodka & Lemonade



Call  $2.00 
Premium  $3.00



Grape Ape

Bourbon, 151 Rum & Grape Punch



Tequila, Triple Sec & Lime Juice



Vodka mixed w/ Chocolate Ice Cream



Cherry with Grain Alcohol & Vodka


Banana Breeze

Vodka, Vanilla Ice Cream & Bananas


Monkey Slush

Non-Alcoholic Blue Raspberry Lemonade


Dirty Monkey

Banana Breeze mixed with Chocohol


Pain in the Ass

Mix of Pina Colada & Rum Runner


Strawberry Margarita

Strawberry Daiquiri & Margarita



Mix of Chocohol & White Russian


The Flying Monkey

Mix of Howler & Ruby Roo


Miami Vice

Pina Colada & Strawberry Daiquiri



Friends & Family

© 2013 Hayes Robertson Group



227 Duval Street

Key West, FL 33040


Tel:  305-294-7525